info@ellisoneditorial.co.uk

Manuscript Evaluation

A manuscript evaluation provides a comprehensive, big-picture review of your manuscript. I assess your book’s structure, plot, character development, pacing, and overall impact, delivering a detailed report with actionable feedback to elevate your story.

What it includes

A thorough analysis of narrative elements (plot, characters, pacing, themes, and style).
A written report (3–5 pages) with strengths, areas for improvement, and specific suggestions.
Optional follow-up consultation to discuss feedback (if requested).

Benefits for authors

Gain clarity on your manuscript’s strengths and weaknesses.
Receive expert insights to refine your story before deeper editing.
Build confidence to revise with clear, constructive feedback tailored to your goals.

What it doesn't include

Line-by-line editing or corrections for grammar, spelling, or punctuation.
Rewriting or restructuring of the manuscript.
Formatting or publishing guidance.

Interested?

Get in touch via the form below or the email address above.
Indicative pricing is shown below. Please note that an exact quote is based on individual manuscripts.

Manuscript Evaluation FAQs

What exactly is a manuscript evaluation, and how does it differ from editing?

A manuscript evaluation is a broad, big-picture assessment of your work. I’ll read your full manuscript and provide a detailed report covering areas such as structure, pacing, plot or argument development, characterisation (if applicable), tone, style, and overall coherence. Unlike editing, I don’t make changes to the text itself – instead, I offer constructive feedback and suggestions to help you strengthen your manuscript before you move on to line editing or copyediting.

Is a manuscript evaluation suitable for early drafts?

Yes – this is often the ideal stage. A manuscript evaluation can highlight key areas to focus on before you spend time polishing language or fine-tuning details. Whether you're uncertain about the structure, need guidance on the manuscript's direction, or want to know how it reads to a critical eye, an evaluation can offer clear next steps.

Will I receive comments on the manuscript itself, or just a report?

My evaluation includes a comprehensive editorial report – typically 3–5 pages depending on the manuscript length and complexity. This outlines what’s working well and what could be improved, with practical suggestions. I may also provide light annotations within the manuscript to illustrate particular points – but the primary feedback comes in the report itself.